top of page
Writer's pictureSiti Khadijah Abdul Malek

Organic Matter vs Organic Fertilizer for Durian Farming in Malaysia


Durian cultivation requires a delicate balance when it comes to soil health, particularly in Malaysia, where the soils can present significant challenges for farmers. The country’s tropical climate, combined with clay-heavy, acidic soils that are low in organic matter, means that durian trees often struggle to thrive without careful management. While many durian farmers understand the importance of organic inputs, there is often confusion around key terms—specifically "organic matter," "organic fertilizer," and "organic carbon." Without clear regulations in Malaysia, these terms are frequently misused or misunderstood, making it difficult for farmers to make informed decisions about soil management.


Organic Matter: What It Is, and What It Isn’t


Organic matter refers to any material that originates from living organisms, whether plant or animal. In Malaysia, organic matter is often used to describe raw or lightly processed agricultural waste, such as empty fruit bunches (EFB) from oil palm, on-farm residues, or other forms of organic plant waste. While this material can be beneficial in some cases, it is important to note that it is not a significant source of essential nutrients like nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), or potassium (K). In fact, these raw forms of organic matter typically contain less than 5% total NPK, meaning they should not be classified as organic fertilizers.

Organic matter can contribute to improving soil structure and microbial activity, but it comes with potential risks. Farmers must be cautious about two critical aspects:

  1. Phytophthora Contamination: Poorly composted organic matter can serve as a vector for Phytophthora, the fungal pathogen responsible for durian canker, a major disease that can devastate durian orchards. In Malaysia’s humid climate, any organic matter that is not fully composted at high temperatures may harbor this pathogen, leading to its spread in the soil and eventually to the durian tree stems.

Nitrogen Immobilization: Many raw or incompletely composted organic materials have a high carbon-to-nitrogen (C:N) ratio, often exceeding 25:1. In Malaysia’s tropical climate, where decomposition is rapid, this imbalance can cause nitrogen immobilization, where the available nitrogen is tied up in the process of breaking down carbon, leaving little nitrogen available for the plants. This can negatively impact durian trees, which have a high demand for nutrients, particularly nitrogen.



Organic Fertilizers: A Step Up from Organic Matter

Unlike raw organic matter, organic fertilizers are designed to not only improve soil quality but also supply significant amounts of NPK. In most countries, organic fertilizers are subject to strict regulations, ensuring that only organic inputs are used and that these fertilizers contain a meaningful percentage of nutrients. Unfortunately, Malaysia lacks clear legal definitions for what constitutes an organic fertilizer, allowing products labeled as "organic" to sometimes contain inorganic sources of NPK. This creates confusion and inconsistency in the quality of products available to durian farmers.

Organic fertilizers provide several advantages over raw organic matter. In well-composted products, the organic matter is lower in carbon, meaning the risk of nitrogen immobilization is reduced. Additionally, these fertilizers often contain humic substances—stable compounds that enhance nutrient retention in soils and support long-term soil fertility.



However, even with organic fertilizers, the threat of Phytophthora remains, particularly if the organic inputs were not composted at sufficiently high temperatures. Given the variability in product quality and the lack of industry standards in Malaysia, farmers must carefully evaluate the sources and composition of any organic fertilizers they apply.


Biofertilizers: The Next Frontier


The solution to many of these challenges may lie in biofertilizers or bio-organic fertilizers. These products not only contain organic matter and nutrients but are also enriched with beneficial microbes and biostimulants that can enhance plant health and nutrient uptake. In Malaysia, a growing number of biofertilizers are becoming available, but two standouts are Diptia and Vitalis, manufactured by Nutrition Technologies.

Diptia and Vitalis are bio-active organic fertilizers made from composted black soldier fly (BSF) frass. Laboratory and greenhouse trials have shown that these products effectively inhibit common pathogens while providing essential macro- and micronutrients. Both products contain high levels of humic and fulvic acids, amino acids, and beneficial bacteria, such as Bacillus halotolerance, which further help to suppress disease and promote healthy plant growth.

Take Diptia, for example: with an 80% organic matter content and a C:N ratio of just 10, it provides high-quality organic inputs that won’t immobilize nitrogen, even in Malaysia’s hot, fast-decomposing tropical soils. Its rich humic and fulvic acid content helps to stabilize soil structure and retain nutrients in the root zone of durian trees, supporting sustained growth and resilience. When applied to durian orchards, Diptia and Vitalis improve soil conditions, supply nutrients, and, crucially, inhibit disease-causing pathogens that might otherwise thrive in poorly composted organic matter.


Building Better Soils for Durian Production


Durian farming in Malaysia presents significant challenges, but by understanding the differences between organic matter, organic fertilizers, and biofertilizers, farmers can make more informed decisions to improve their soil health and crop productivity. While organic matter can improve soil structure, it must be fully composted to avoid transferring harmful pathogens and causing nitrogen immobilization. Organic fertilizers offer a more reliable source of nutrients, but the lack of standards in Malaysia means that product quality can vary widely.



Biofertilizers like Diptia and Vitalis represent a new frontier in durian cultivation. These products combine high-quality composted organic matter with beneficial microbes that enhance nutrient availability and protect against disease, offering a more complete solution for farmers aiming to build resilient, productive soils for durian trees. By incorporating these bio-active fertilizers into their soil management practices, durian farmers in Malaysia can not only boost their yields but also safeguard their crops

from the many challenges posed by the tropical environment.





23 views0 comments

Comentários


bottom of page